Unlocking the Door to Medicine: How Early VCE Subjects Are Shaping Future Doctors
Imagine a high school student, like Melbourne High School’s Daniel Wanglikitkoon, already charting a course toward a career in medicine before even finishing Year 12. Sounds ambitious, right? But here’s where it gets fascinating: Daniel, a Year 12 student with a knack for maths and physics, decided to dive into VCE Biology a year early, in Year 11. This strategic move not only expanded his scientific horizons but also catapulted him into the ranks of top-scoring VCE Biology students, earning a stellar 48 out of 50. His success is no isolated incident—it’s part of a broader trend at Melbourne High, which has seen sustained rises in top VCE scores over the past decade, particularly in subjects like Biology. But here’s where it gets controversial: Is starting VCE subjects early the secret sauce to academic success, or does it risk overwhelming students too soon? Let’s explore.
The Age’s newly launched Victorian Schools Guide (https://www.theage.com.au/victorian-schools-guide) sheds light on this phenomenon, offering an interactive dashboard that allows parents and students to scrutinize the performance of government, Catholic, and independent schools across the state. Updated regularly and set to include new features, this tool is a game-changer for families navigating school choices. The data reveals that schools like Melbourne High, Loreto Mandeville Hall, and Melbourne Grammar School have seen remarkable improvements in subjects such as Biology, Legal Studies, and Business Management, respectively. But what’s driving these successes?
And this is the part most people miss: It’s not just about early subject enrollment. Schools attribute their achievements to a trifecta of strategies: students taking Year 12 subjects early, past high achievers returning as mentors, and teachers laying robust foundational knowledge in the early years. For instance, Melbourne High’s Biology program has seen a dramatic rise in top scores, jumping from 16 students achieving 40+ in 2016 to 48 in 2024. Josh Slocombe, the school’s VCE coordinator, credits this to Year 11 students’ ability to focus solely on Biology without the distractions of other subjects. But is this laser-focused approach sustainable for all students, or does it risk burnout?
At Loreto Mandeville Hall, the “Year 13” mentoring program stands out. Former Year 12 students return to guide current pupils, offering direct feedback and serving as role models. Jill Fitzsimons, director of teaching and learning, highlights how mentors provide insights that teachers might not. For example, Sophie Hill, who scored 48 in Legal Studies, attributes her success to engaging discussions about real-life cases, like Erin Patterson’s trial (https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/the-seven-reasons-mushroom-murderer-erin-patterson-wants-her-conviction-quashed-20251105-p5n7uq.html). But does this reliance on mentorship create an uneven playing field for students without access to such resources?
Meanwhile, Melbourne Grammar School’s Business Management program has seen a fourfold increase in top scores since 2017. Lisa Ritchie, head of commerce, emphasizes the importance of foundational subjects like “Dollars and Sense” in Year 8 and entrepreneurship in Year 9. She also stresses the value of lifting the entire cohort, not just the high achievers. But is this approach enough to address the widening gap between top performers and struggling students?
Extracurricular activities play a pivotal role too. Teachers at Melbourne Grammar, like Ritchie, engage with students through sports programs, fostering relationships that extend beyond the classroom. But does this blur the line between academic and personal life, potentially leading to over-involvement?
As we reflect on these strategies, one question lingers: Are these schools creating well-rounded, resilient students, or are they merely producing high scores at the expense of holistic development? What do you think? Share your thoughts in the comments below and let’s spark a conversation about the future of education. Don’t forget to start your day informed—sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter (https://www.theage.com.au/link/follow-20170101-p57ogt) for the latest insights and analysis.
From our partners
