Here’s the harsh truth: the Cincinnati Reds’ roster, despite its recent upgrades, is missing a crucial piece—a seasoned veteran who can provide depth, experience, and a touch of unpredictability. But here’s where it gets controversial: while the team has bolstered its lineup with the return of Eugenio Suárez and boasts an enviable starting rotation, there’s no one on the roster who fits the mold of a ‘reclamation project’—a player who’s been there, done that, but might just need a tweak to reclaim their former glory. And this is the part most people miss: that kind of player could be the difference between a good season and a great one.
Let’s break it down. Suárez’s addition is undoubtedly a win, but it’s not without its trade-offs. Players like Spencer Steer, Sal Stewart, Ke’Bryan Hayes, and JJ Bleday will see their paths to consistent playing time complicated by the roster’s flexibility. Yet, this flexibility is a strength, especially when injuries or slumps inevitably arise. The same goes for the starting rotation, which is stacked with talent like Hunter Greene, Andrew Abbott, and Nick Lodolo. But as any baseball fan knows, you can never have too much pitching depth. Last season alone, the Reds leaned on Nick Martinez for 165.2 innings and traded for Zack Littell at the deadline, proving that even the deepest rotations need reinforcements.
This brings us to the heart of the matter: the absence of a veteran pitcher who can fill multiple roles without being relied upon as a cornerstone. Someone like Wade Miley, who signed last year as a low-risk, high-reward option. Miley wasn’t expected to be a savior, but his presence provided depth and experience—a luxury the Reds don’t currently have. Here’s the bold part: the Reds need a player who fits this mold, someone who’s been an ace but might be overlooked due to recent struggles. Someone like Walker Buehler.
Buehler, a two-time All-Star and World Series champion, has seen his career derailed by injuries, including major elbow surgery. His recent stats are underwhelming, but at just 31 years old, there’s a chance he could rediscover his form. What makes Buehler particularly intriguing? He’s a Reds fan from Kentucky, with ties to Derek Johnson’s coaching legacy at Vanderbilt. But here’s the controversial question: Is Buehler willing to accept a role that doesn’t guarantee a spot in the starting rotation? And are the Reds willing to take a chance on him?
The Reds’ current roster is undeniably strong, but it lacks that wildcard element—a player who could be a game-changer if everything clicks. Buehler, or someone like him, could be that player. He wouldn’t need to be ready on Opening Day or pitch six innings every fifth day immediately. Instead, he could start as a reliever, eat innings when needed, and potentially work his way back into a starting role. Even if it doesn’t pan out, the risk is minimal, much like the Miley signing last year.
As the offseason winds down, some team will take a chance on a player like Buehler. Here’s the thought-provoking question for you: Why shouldn’t that team be the Reds? With their depth and coaching staff, they’re perfectly positioned to unlock a veteran’s potential. So, what do you think? Is Buehler the missing piece, or is there another player out there who fits the bill? Let’s hear your take in the comments!
